Rechercher
Fermer ce champ de recherche.

Is there a link between immigration and insecurity?

Are foreigners more delinquent than nationals? It's a question that shapes many debates around the world. Cs Actu has examined reports and statistics produced by associations and organizations to shed light on this “mystery”. France will be taken as an example throughout this analysis, as it has a vast array of easily accessible, quantified studies. Given that the situation is similar in many Western countries, we can conclude that this article (apart from the figures) is just as relevant for analyzing other states.

Partagez ce post

Foreigners over-represented in delinquency and crime figures

To begin with, foreigners are indeed over-represented in delinquency and crime figures. Today, foreigners represent 7.6% of the population of France, or 5.2 million people. However, they account for 17.7% of people implicated by the police and gendarmerie, according to INSEE. Also, foreigners account for 23.2% of the prison population in France, according to the International Prison Observatory.

Source : Insee

These figures are one of the bases for the argument that we need to fight immigration in order to combat delinquency and crime.

However, is there really a link between immigration and delinquency/crime, or are there other factors that could explain these figures?

Figures need to be qualified

First, it’s important to qualify the figures. Foreigners are over-represented in crime figures. However, the reasons why they are brought to justice are essentially economic or financial offences (counterfeiting, street vending) and theft. Foreigners can also be guilty of offences that only they can commit. Like the offence of being undocumented. This inflates the figures without adding any relevance.

Secondly, a foreigner is more likely to be checked than a native. According to a 2017 survey by the Défenseur des droits, 16% of the population claimed to have been checked at least once in the last 5 years. Among people under 25 perceived as black or Arab, 80% said they had already been checked in the last 5 years. A difference of 64 points.

Source : Défenseur des Droits

Secondly, foreign offenders and criminals are judged more severely than nationals. They are more likely to face a prison sentence than natives for the same offence or crime. Their prison sentences are also longer.

Source : Calculations by the authors of “Marianne” based on Casier judiciaire national (National Criminal Record), Sub-Directorate of Statistics and Studies (SDSE), Ministry of Justice.

Note: “With similar characteristics” means that differences in sentences between foreigners and French nationals are calculated for individuals of the same age, sex, criminal record, date and place of trial, who have committed the same type of offence and followed the same procedure.

Reading: foreigners are 5.16% more likely to receive a prison sentence than natives of the same sex, age, criminal record, etc.

Source : Calculations by the authors of “Marianne” based on Casier judiciaire national (National Criminal Record), Sub-Directorate of Statistics and Studies (SDSE), Ministry of Justice.

Note: “With similar characteristics” means that differences in sentences between foreigners and French nationals are calculated for individuals of the same age, sex, criminal record, date and place of trial, who have committed the same type of offence and followed the same procedure.

Reading: foreigners have on average 20.91 days more of a prison sentence than a native of the same sex, age, criminal record, etc.

Three-quarters of immigrants (74%) are aged between 18 and 64, compared to just over half (56%) of non-immigrants. This means that foreigners are more likely to be in an age group where deviance is “more common”.

Taking these analyses into account, it is already more difficult to assert that foreigners are more deviant than natives.

A poorer population

With a poverty rate of around 11% (EU average 16%), France is one of the EU countries with the lowest poverty rate. However, with a poverty rate for foreigners of 28%, France is above the EU average (26%). This gap between natives and foreigners is even more apparent with people who arrived less than 10 years ago, 40% of whom are in poverty, according to the European Commission and the OECD.

Source : European Commission, OECD

Foreigners are also more affected by unemployment (13%) than natives (7%). They are also in poorer health, have more difficulties at school, do more arduous work, live in more overcrowded housing, and so on. Another factor, more specific to France, is discrimination. France is the second country (neck and neck with Italy) with the highest number of complaints of discrimination based on ethnic criteria. According to the OECD, this concerns 20.5% of foreigners living in France.

Poverty leads to more deviance

According to the French section of the International Prison Observatory, poverty and social insecurity lead to greater deviance. In France, 45% of people surveyed on entering prison are poor (compared with 11% of the general population).

Source : French section of the International Prison Observatory, Insee

55% had no permanent employment contract before entering prison (compared with 35% of the overall population). 28% were living with a relative, and 8% were homeless (compared to 0.5% of the overall population).

Poverty and, more broadly, a poor social and economic situation are therefore major factors in deviance.

Conclusion

Immigration is a complex subject on which many fantasies are confusedly based. In fact, foreigners are over-represented in delinquency/crime figures. However, statistics show that it’s not because they come from foreign countries that they are more deviant. Poverty, unemployment, discrimination, are factors that generally lead to an increase in deviance, regardless of a person’s nationality or ethnic origin.

Also, the wealth created by foreigners is vital to keep a flagging system running. Discriminating further or limiting immigration would impoverish the system and, by extension, the population as a whole. Statistically, this would ultimately make the streets less safe.

12 comments
  1. helloI like your writing very so much proportion we keep up a correspondence extra approximately your post on AOL I need an expert in this space to unravel my problem May be that is you Taking a look forward to see you

  2. you are in reality a good webmaster The website loading velocity is amazing It sort of feels that youre doing any distinctive trick Also The contents are masterwork you have done a fantastic job in this topic

  3. I share your level of appreciation for the work you’ve produced. The sketch is refined, and the authored material is stylish. However, you appear anxious about the prospect of embarking on something that could be considered questionable. I believe you’ll be able to rectify this matter in a timely manner.

  4. Temp mail You’re so awesome! I don’t believe I have read a single thing like that before. So great to find someone with some original thoughts on this topic. Really.. thank you for starting this up. This website is something that is needed on the internet, someone with a little originality!

  5. Real Estate You’re so awesome! I don’t believe I have read a single thing like that before. So great to find someone with some original thoughts on this topic. Really.. thank you for starting this up. This website is something that is needed on the internet, someone with a little originality!

Laisser un commentaire

Votre adresse e-mail ne sera pas publiée. Les champs obligatoires sont indiqués avec *

Total
0
Share

CSMAG, votre point actu’ mensuel !

Nous souhaitons faire de ce magazine le reflet de l’esprit de CSactu, en y intégrant toute nos nouveautés : articles de fond, podcasts, émissions sur Twitch, conférences et bien plus encore. 

Chaque mois, nous nous engageons à vous offrir un magazine qui, tout en valorisant le travail de notre rédaction, mettra en lumière l’ensemble des initiatives portées par CSactu.